The original post from which this essay stems was published nearly 20 years ago. There has been much geopolitical and spiritual change over those two decades, and I thought it important—during today’s heated discussions of war in Iran—to revisit the topic and the essays related to it. My aim in rewriting and republishing these is not to persuade toward one position or another. Rather, it is to encourage Christians to examine how they think about topics such as war. My hope is that we will devote ourselves to honing the tools we use to guide or control and express our positions on serious topics, including war. Once sharpened, these same intellectual and spiritual tools enable us to think about and speak to other political and cultural issues of the day from the perspective of a soul enrobed by the Spirit of Christ and devoted to the Lord.
In the multitude of evils that are a part of human experience, war and the destruction and carnage that follow in its wake rank in the top tier of wickedness. War has been a constant of human history and, despite the promise of the transforming power of Jesus Christ, He said that we “will hear of wars and rumors of wars” (Matthew 24:6), that it will be with us until the end of days. Given this constant from Jesus, a Christian’s worldview should be discipled in a biblical way of considering political violence and to have a framework from which we determine our thoughts and actions in relation to the act of war. The Christian is under competing pressures from being a citizen of the Kingdom of Christ and, simultaneously, being a good member of society. Many questions come our way in the ‘already, but not yet’ life we live. Shall we declare ourselves to be conscientious objectors when the country that supports the foundation of our religious liberty is under attack? Can we determine for certain that a war is ‘just’ in the classical definition of the term? Is pacifism the only acceptable stance a Christian can take? These questions sketch some ideas that a spirit-led Christian must wrestle with in approaching the Christlike commitment to seeking peace amidst the ongoing reality of war.
There is a substantial body of work created by Christian and secular thinkers to which we can turn to shape our thinking on the subjects of violence and war. Christianity through the centuries has engaged the full range of philosophy toward war, from full participation to absolute prohibition. If asked, can you define your position and defend it in the heated arena of ideas? Taking a prohibitionary stance that disallows Christian participation in war, for example, is simple to hold but challenging to explain when it means that not-yet-God’s-people non-Christians must be sent to fight in one’s place. Coming to a settled position on this and other hot-button issues of the day requires a familiarity of multiple topics that all contribute to the discussion. The philosophy of ethics is important in considering Just War theory. The imago dei must be held against the use of violence in creating or preserving peace. To engage in the arena of ideas demands that we be able to understand the positions of those with whom we might disagree.
The Bible is the primary resource from which Christians develop their beliefs and worldview, and even a cursory knowledge of the text shows us that war has been a reality for God’s people throughout history. Early in the Old Testament we encounter widespread war commanded by God of His people. In the book of Joshua, we turn the page to be confronted with wars of outright aggression fought with the explicit intent of taking territory. Yahweh sends Israel into battles of conquest with the instruction to “not leave alive anything that breathes. Completely destroy them…” (Deuteronomy 20:16-17) and to Joshua (Ch 6) the command is to see to the total destruction of Jericho, soldier and citizen alike. This same God will later stand on a mountainside and pronounce a blessing on those who seek peace (Matthew 5:9) and press His listeners to “love their enemies” (Matthew 5:44). The Christian not only needs to hold these (seemingly) contradictory points in hand but devote themselves to knowing the God who gives them and try to understand what lies behind the commands. New questions arise that shape our position: Is God in support of war, despite the destruction and loss of life that follow? What of the words of Christ that even non-Christians can quote to ‘turn the other cheek’ in the face of evil? Is God of two minds? Certainly not, but the complexity of thinking about war and how Christians should think through the topic is clear.
As difficult as the subject of war might be, we must consider the topic to some depth as disciples. We should be able to articulate the position we hold with clarity. The importance of our gospel presence requires of the Christian that we soberly and carefully determine the position we hold given our calling to be light in the dark world.






